Air Fryer Grilled Cheese - Air Fryer Eats - Easy Air Fryer Recipe (2024)

Is there anything more nostalgic than a grilled cheese sandwich? With this air fryer recipe, you can make perfectly toasted, buttery air fryer grilled cheese every single time!

Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

Air Fryer Grilled Cheese is an easy-to-make recipe that yields the most scrumptious results.

If you've never made a grilled cheese sandwich in your air fryer, you've been missing out!

In only 10 minutes you'll have the most buttery, crispy-on-the-outside, ooey-gooey cheesy-on-the-inside grilled cheese sandwich ever!

Serve it with a crispy pile of air fryer tater tots or air fryer French fries and an icy milkshake and you'll have a diner-style meal that will take you back to your childhood!

The Best Bread for Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

It's the question folks have been asking for ages - which type of bread makes the best grilled cheese?

The truth is, it's all about personal preference!

If you want to make a super crispy, crunchy grilled cheese, I recommend using just about any plain old white bread or sourdough.

Look for bread that has a nice even grain, not too porous, but not too dense.

With this air fryer grilled cheese recipe, we're aiming for a sandwich that has a nice bread to cheese ratio.

I like to use white bread, but you can use any brand or variety that you prefer.

How to Make the Best Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

You won't believe how simple this recipe is!

Here's how to make the best grilled cheese sandwich around:

1. The first step is to butter one side of each piece of bread. You can use salted or unsalted butter. Make sure that you spread the butter evenly across the slice from crust to crust.
2. Place a piece or two of cheese between the two slices of bread, making sure that the buttered sides are facing outward.
3. Place the sandwich into the bottom of your air fryer basket.
4. Cook as directed by the recipe, making sure to flip your grilled cheese sandwich around halfway through cooking to ensure that both sides crisp up evenly.

Grilled Cheese Sandwich Tips

Tuck the grilled cheese securely inside the sandwich before air frying. If the cheese sticks out of the sides of the sandwich, it will burn due to the high heat of the air fryer.

Simply fold the edges of the cheese and tuck them inside the bread beforehand to avoid burning.

Don't forget to butter the bread. Without butter, you won't get that super crispy crunch on the outside of your toasted cheese sandwich.

Place the buttered side of the bread out. Watch for fly away bread! Air fryers work like convection ovens, circling hot air around your food.

The bread from your sandwich may not stay in place due to the air inside your air fryer.

If this happens, you can place a wire rack from your air fryer or instant pot over your sandwich to keep everything in place. If you are a total cheese lover and want to make your meal extra cheesy! Serve it with this 5 cheese mac and cheese!

Try these other easy air fryer recipes!

We have so many air fryer recipes to choose from!

If you are having trouble figuring out which one to try next, we suggest: Air Fryer Hamburgers, Air Fryer Chicken Tenders, Air Fryer Fried Chicken and Air Fryer Hotdogs

Pro Tips

• Use Any Air Fryer:This recipe can be made in an air fryer unit with a basket or an air fryer oven. If you're using an air fryer oven, place your food on the middle rack and select the "air fry" function.
• Check your food as it cooks!Since each air fryer runs differently, sometimes air frying is a trial and error process. When cooking a new recipe, be sure to check on your food often. This will help you avoid over or undercooking, and help you learn your air fryer's specific ways!

Have you made this recipe? Please leave a comment AND rating below! It helps other readers!

Be sure to tag @AirFryerEats on instagram, if you share a picture on the gram!

Let's get social, you can follow me on Youtube, Instagram, Facebook, Pinterest or join one of our Air Fryer Facebook Groups: Air Fryer Recipes, Air Fryer Recipes for Seniors and Gluten Free Air Fryer Recipes.

Don't forget to subscribe to our EMAIL newsletter.